— Austen Ivereigh (@austeni) July 17, 2017
Thank you for your blog. I get so much from it! Never stop!
Question - Time
I know you like one question at a time, but maybe you’ll do this.
 Why do you think Benedict XVI never said the Extraordinary Form while we was Pope?
People - Mass - Parishes
 What should lay people do to get the old Mass in their parishes?
 How do you see the future of the Extraordinary Form?
Thanks - Answers
Thanks for answers to one or all!
Thanks for that. No link to that podcast, so I am a bit hobbled. However, I can’t imagine that they said anything strange. These are smart guys.
Benedict - XVI - Form
1) Why didn’t Benedict XVI never say the Extraordinary Form?
He certainly did not, as Pope, celebrate the Extraordinary Form in public. However, I suspect he could have privately now and then. I say that because, once in while, during Masses I thought I spotted him doing some things that I must be very careful about when I say the Novus Ordo. I don’t say the Novus Ordo very often, and I get into “autopilot”, for example, automatically genuflecting at certain points, automatically tucking the paten, etc. But, that’s not really the question.
Reasons - Benedict - Form - Arguments
I think there were two reasons why Benedict didn’t publicly say the Extraordinary Form. I am convinced that he would have liked to, so there must have been compelling arguments against.
One argument is that to mount a Papal Mass, not just a Pontifical Mass would have been extremely difficult. It was already difficult at the time of John XXIII (who was reviving liturgical uses) and Paul VI (who abolished it all). I used to argue on this blog that Benedict could celebrate not a Papal Mass but at least a Pontifical Mass. I haven’t entirely abandoned that, but it would be seriously deficient. The Pope must be the Pope and must not be just...
Wake Up To Breaking News!
If the Government could just stop...