Clarity About Nationalism

Townhall | 6/25/2019 | Staff
shankay (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo:

In order to make arguments for nationalism, we have to define it.

The first definition in Merriam-Webster is "loyalty and devotion to a nation." But in a second paragraph, it adds, "especially: a sense of national consciousness exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups."

Paragraph - Definition - Nationalism - Nationalism - Thing

Let's be clear: If the second paragraph is the only definition of nationalism, nationalism is always a bad thing. Furthermore, I acknowledge that this definition is what some people have in mind when they call themselves nationalists.

At the same time, even anti-nationalists would have to acknowledge that if the first paragraph is the definition of "nationalism," nationalism can often be a beautiful thing.

Answer - Question - Nationalism

So, if we are to be honest, the answer to the question of whether nationalism is good or bad is "How do you define it?" offers seven definitions.

Aspirations - Nation

The first is "spirit or aspirations common to the whole nation."

The second is "devotion and loyalty to one's own country; patriotism."

Definition - Definition - Patriotism

Only when we get to the third definition is the definition pejorative: "excessive patriotism; chauvinism."

Therefore, a) based on the competing definitions of the term, b) assuming both definitions can be true and c) if intellectual honesty is to govern our discussion, we can reach only one conclusion: There is good nationalism and bad nationalism.

Nationalism - Nationalism - Assessment

That -- not "nationalism is always good" or "nationalism is always bad" -- is the only accurate assessment.

Therefore, morally speaking, nationalism is no different from anything else in life.

Violence - Self-defense - Defense - Innocents - Defense

There is moral violence (in self-defense, in defense of innocents, in defense of a society under unjust attack, etc.) and immoral violence (murder of innocents, wars of aggression, etc.).

There is moral sex (consensual sex between adults and, in the Judeo-Christian value system, within marriage) and immoral sex (such...
(Excerpt) Read more at: Townhall
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Sorry Mr. Franklin, we couldn't keep it.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!