Kirsten Powers, Abortion & Church Teaching

Juicy Ecumenism | 5/21/2019 | Mark Tooley
doona07doona07 (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo:

Commentator Kirsten Powers wrote a USA Today column lamenting recent state initiatives to limit abortion, describing herself as both “pro-choice and pro-life.” She recalled her own conversion to Evangelicalism a decade ago and more recent induction into Roman Catholicism. She wrote:

Of course the Roman Catholic Church, which Powers has joined, has an emphatic teaching about the humanity of unborn human life and its merits for protection by civil society. Many social and political issues are matters of prudential judgment. But for Roman Catholics, their church’s teaching on abortion is binding.

Protestant - Catholics - Converts - Church - Truth

As a Protestant, I’ve always been perplexed by committed Catholics, especially adult converts, who presumably have carefully pondered their church’s truth claims, and then reject or minimize them. Why join or remain with an institution and faith tradition whose core premises are faulty?

Powers is a journalist and thought leader who presumably was catechized in Catholic teaching during her induction into the church. She knows this church has a very long, deep and reach ethical tradition about human life that cannot be encapsulated by a few Bible verses. Yet in her column she does not engage her church’s teaching at all. Instead she treats the issue as merely another hot button in American culture wars.

Catholics - Powers - Protestant - Truth - Claims

Some ardent Catholics might dismiss Powers as a de facto Protestant, asserting sweeping truth claims against the Roman Catholic Church based on individual preference alone. But this caricature, although found among many individual Protestants, is not true of classic Protestantism.

Every major stream of historic Christianity, including Protestants, Catholics and Orthodox, believe in a corporate Body of Christ alive across millennia and all cultures, sustained by the Holy Spirit. No individual Christian in any church is left isolated to craft his or her own corpus of ethical teachings. Instead, wonderfully, every Christian has...
(Excerpt) Read more at: Juicy Ecumenism
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Sign In or Register to comment.