Does “Beans” @MassimoFaggioli undermine ‘Humanae vitae’?

wdtprs.com | 7/12/2018 | View all posts by Fr. John Zuhlsdorf →
finter (Posted by) Level 4


The war on the teaching of Humanae vitae continued today with an offering at ultra-liberal Commonweal by Massimo “Beans” Faggioli. Beans spends a lot of time on Twitter throwing our one inflammatory tweet after another as click bait.

Faggioli takes his starting point from the release of a new book, in Italian, by Gilfredo Marengo about how Humanae vitae came to be promulgated. What he is really up to, however, is sowing doubt about the dependability of the content of Humanae vitae under the guise of making it is genesis understandable.

Beans - Humanae - Vitae - Catholic - University

Beans doesn’t indicate that he adheres to Humanae vitae even though he teaches at a Catholic university and he should, therefore, have a mandatum.

First, note his title:

Others - Development

If he and others can show that its development was contentious, then maybe you don’t have to adhere to it.

Then, inter alia, look at his numbers game:

Fact - Marengo - Book - Paul - VI

Another important fact revealed in Marengo’s book has to do with Paul VI’s request to the bishops gathered at the synod of October 1967 that they send him suggestions about a magisterial document on the regulation of fertility. Of the more than two hundred members of the synod, only twenty-six replied between October 1967 and May 1968—and only seven of these twenty-six recommended that Paul VI confirm Pius XI’s prohibition of contraception. Among the bishops in favor of a shift in teaching away from Pius XI’s Casti connubii were not only well-known European progressives like Suenens (Brussels), Döpfner (Munich), and Legér (Montreal), but also the U.S. prelates Dearden (Detroit) [spectacularly liberal], Krol (Philadelphia) [a social liberal who covered up sex abuse], Shehan (Baltimore) [spectacularly liberal], and Wright (Pittsburgh) [supporter of Charles Curran].

Two hundred members of the synod, of which 26 replied, of whom 19 (of 200) wanted the Church’s perennial teaching to be overturned. And that is a big...
(Excerpt) Read more at: wdtprs.com
Wake Up To Breaking News!
I find it extremely funny when people keep voting and expecting the government to change!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!